The City of Fresno is suing the Fresno Arts Council Inc. and members of its leadership to hold the nonprofit legally and financially accountable for the loss of more than $1.5 million in Measure P tax dollars.
The Office of the Fresno City Attorney announced the lawsuit Thursday. The city filed it at the direction of the Fresno City Council.
Former Arts Council Operations Manager Suliana Caldwell siphoned away more than $1.8 million in public and organizational funds to fund personal vacations and gamble at local casinos. Caldwell was sentenced in August to 33 months in federal prison.
Caldwell, 47, is currently incarcerated at the Federal Correctional Complex, Victorville, according to Federal Bureau of Prisons records.
“Fresno voters approved Measure P to support local arts and enrich our neighborhoods — not to bankroll an embezzler’s gambling sprees while the Fresno Arts Council completely failed in its duty to watch the books,” said Fresno City Attorney Andrew Janz. “Sending one employee to federal prison does not let the Fresno Arts Council off the hook for its gross negligence and breach of contract. We are taking them to court to aggressively claw back every single dollar stolen from Fresno taxpayers.”
Because the case is in active litigation, the city attorney’s office said it would not comment further.
Arts Council responds
Jackson Waste of the Fennemore law firm, representing the Arts Council, and Adam Stirrup, who represents 12 named board members, responded jointly.
“The Fresno Arts Council was the victim of a crime,” the attorneys said. “The money that was stolen was not stolen from the City of Fresno. It was stolen from the Fresno Arts Council.”
The attorneys noted the contract calls for an annual independent audit funded and coordinated by the city’s Department of Finance.
“Our opinion is that (1) any competent ‘independent audit’ would have detected Ms. Caldwell’s embezzlement of the Fresno Arts Council’s funds, and (2) the City of Fresno is blaming the Fresno Arts Council, and the community members who volunteered to serve on its Board, for the City’s own failure to conduct adequate oversight,” they said. “Our clients intend to vigorously defend themselves against this meritless lawsuit.”
Who is named
The complaint, filed in Fresno County Superior Court, names the Arts Council, Caldwell, PayPal Inc. and 16 people it describes as Arts Council officers, executives or board members since 2021: CEO Lilia Gonzalez-Chavez, Harpreet Gill, Sal Lucatero, Olga Nunez, Karen Simpson, Olga Gutierrez de Nunez, Jolene Telles, Dee Dee Buchanan, Julia Copeland, Thomas Ellis, Alana Hill, Tiffany Mangum, Priscilla Ross, Kirin Sran, Kevin Stewart-Magree and Lauren Nikkel.
Claims include breach of contract, negligence, negligent misrepresentation and fraud.
What the complaint alleges
Caldwell managed the Arts Council’s bank accounts, payroll and finances and was the only person who received its monthly bank statements, according to the complaint. Beginning in June 2022, she made unauthorized transfers to her personal PayPal and bank accounts, using Gonzalez-Chavez’s PayPal login.
The transfers increased significantly in 2023, when the Arts Council began receiving Measure P funds under an agreement with the city, the complaint states. The city sent the Arts Council $9.72 million in November 2023 and $5.71 million in October 2024.
In September 2024, the Arts Council told the city no grants had been awarded the previous fiscal year, a claim the city believes was untrue.
In early 2026, Measure P grant checks to artists began bouncing, and Caldwell was fired for cause over excessive absences. Fresno police opened an investigation Feb. 6. Caldwell confessed to police and the FBI on March 26 and entered a federal plea agreement April 8.
In all, Caldwell took more than $1.82 million in Measure P funds through more than 300 transfers, the complaint states.
The PayPal money
At the center of the dispute is $901,884.83 that PayPal returned to the Arts Council. The city says the money belongs to taxpayers and has demanded it. The Arts Council says it is holding the funds in a segregated account, according to the complaint.
Caldwell was ordered in September to pay the city $1.17 million in restitution.
The city is asking the court to order the Arts Council to return the PayPal funds and indemnify the city for $2.1 million in attorney and expert fees and losses tied to the agreement.
