JESSICA GRESKO Associated Press" />
citrus

A worker at the Fowler Packing Co. places bags of oranges into boxes to be sent to stores in this 2017 file photo.

published on June 23, 2021 - 9:15 AM
Written by

The Supreme Court on Wednesday sided with California agriculture businesses in their challenge to a state regulation that gives unions access to farm property in order to organize workers. As a result of the ruling, California will have to modify or abandon the regulation put in place in 1975 after the efforts of labor leader Cesar Chavez.

Fresno-based Fowler Packing Co., which ships grapes and citrus, was involved in the case as was Cedar Point Nursery in Dorris, which grows strawberry plants for commercial growers.

The justices ruled 6-3 along ideological lines for the agriculture businesses. It’s another potential setback for unions as a result of a high court decision.

“The access regulation amounts to simple appropriation of private property,” Chief Justice John Roberts wrote for the conservative members of the court.

At issue was a regulation that granted unions access to farms and other agriculture businesses for up to three hours per day, 120 days per year, in order to organize workers. Businesses are supposed to be notified before organizers arrive, and organizers are supposed to come during nonwork times such as lunch and before and after work.

The businesses that brought the case to the court argued that California’s regulation was unconstitutional, but was also outdated and unnecessary given that unions can now reach workers many ways, including via smartphone and radio.

Sacramento-based law firm Pacific Legal Foundation argued on behalf of both Fowler Packing and Cedar Point Nursery. Attorneys argued that allowing a third party onto someone else’s property without compensation violates property rights, according to a press release from Pacific Legal Foundation.

“This decision protects everyone’s freedom to decide for themselves who is — and is not — allowed on their own property,” said Mike Fahner, owner of Cedar Point Nursery in the release. “We’re very happy with the Court’s ruling today, and we’re excited to keep running our businesses without unlawful interference.”

Representatives from United Farm Workers or Fowler Packing were not immediately available for comment.

The access regulation is unique to California. But unions and others had argued that ruling for the businesses could threaten regulations that allow government to access private property to conduct workplace health and safety inspections, among other things.

The ruling is the latest hit to unions by the court under Roberts. In 2018, the court’s conservative majority overturned a 41-year-old pro-union decision that had allowed states to require that public employees pay some fees to unions that represent them, even if the workers choose not to join.

Still, it’s unclear how much will change as a result of the court’s ruling.

California had said that union organizers use the regulation “sparingly” – only five times in the 2019-2020 budget year and 24 times in 2018-2019. Still, the United Farmworkers of America told the justices that the regulation is more necessary now than ever. The union said farmworkers are increasingly indigenous workers from Mexico and the only effective way to communicate with them is in person at their job sites.

In court documents filed before President Joe Biden took office, the Trump administration had urged the justices to side with the businesses. The Biden administration later changed the government’s position.

Union organizers used California’s regulation to go on to Cedar Point’s property in 2015. That same year, union organizers complained Fowler Packing Company interfered with their ability to access company property for three days. That complaint was later withdrawn.

The case is Cedar Point Nursery v. Hassid, 20-107.

The Business Journal contributed to this reporting.


e-Newsletter Signup

Our Weekly Poll

Have you ever worked with a sociopath (antisocial behaviors, lack of conscience)?
65 votes

Central Valley Biz Blogs

Popup

3/5

Article views

remaining

Sign up icon

To continue website access to

TheBusinessJournal.com

please create a FREE account OR login here.

1/5

Article views

remaining

SKIP THE POP-UPS
For only $59 for one 1-year you will receive the Print edition along with EVERYTHING The Business Journal has to offer digitally, PLUS you will have unlimited 24- hour a day access to view articles at

TheBusinessJournal.com

Use Promo Code

*New Subscribers Only

Digital and Print

XX Days Remaining

until you can view 5 more free articles

Sign up icon

Want access? Subscribe now & save $20 OFF.

Use Promo Code

WEBSUB20

* NEW SUBSCRIBERS ONLY