Beginning Jan. 1, 2019, people will have to request straws for use in their drinks. Photo by Edward Smith.
Written by Associated Press
(AP) — If you want a straw with your drink or a soda with a kids’ meal at a California restaurant, you’ll need to ask for them starting next year.
A law signed Thursday by Gov. Jerry Brown makes California the first state to bar full-service restaurants from automatically giving out single-use plastic straws. Another bill he signed requires milk or water to be the default drink sold with kids’ meals at fast-food and full-service restaurants.
Neither law is an outright ban on straws or sugary drinks in kids’ meals. But some Republicans have called the measures government overreach by the heavily Democratic state.
California restaurants that don’t comply with the straw law will get two warnings before being fined. Lawmakers changed the legislation to add a $300 annual fine limit. It will apply only to sit-down restaurants where customers are waited on by restaurant staff, not fast-food establishments.
Health inspectors will be responsible for enforcing the law.
Nancy Brown, the CEO of the American Heart Association, came out in praise of the beverage bill, saying it makes it “easier to raise healthy kids.”
“California has made history today by becoming the first state to ensure that water or milk comes standard for kids’ meals at all restaurants,” Brown said in a press release. She went on to say “we strongly encourage other states and communities to follow suit, and we call on restaurants nationwide to take immediate action on their own by removing unhealthy drinks from kids’ meals.”
The Heart Association cited data that claim half of meals in the U.S. are purchased outside of the home. Of their total caloric intake, children get an average of 25 percent daily from food and drinks at a restaurant. Drinking water and milk with those meals reduces the chances for heart disease and diabetes, the association said.
Democratic lawmakers who support the straw policy call it a small step toward reducing ocean pollution.
Brown, who has made environmental issues a signature priority, pointed to the large amount of plastic dumped in oceans every year that can kill whales and fish and contaminate people’s food and water supplies.
“Plastic has helped advance innovation in our society, but our infatuation with single-use convenience has led to disastrous consequences,” Brown said in a statement. “Plastics, in all forms — straws, bottles, packaging, bags, etc. — are choking the planet.”
California’s law doesn’t go as far as those in cities, including San Francisco and Seattle, that ban straws outright.
Critics argue California’s straw law won’t significantly improve the environment. Some say restricting straws hurts disabled people who rely on them.
And some lawmakers who voted against the measure said it would unfairly punish restaurants, although the restaurant industry didn’t oppose the proposal.
The law doesn’t address the biggest causes of plastic ocean pollution, such as fishing nets, and doesn’t apply to some of the biggest users of plastic straws: fast-food restaurants, said Tod Hardin, director of operations and communications for the nonprofit Plastic Oceans International.
“That in some ways makes it a little bit weaker than we would have hoped for, but it’s a step toward changing behavior and raising awareness,” he said. “It’s a move in a positive direction.”
The sugary drink law will still let restaurants and fast food chains sell soda or juice with children’s meals. But it says only milk; a non-dairy milk alternative; or sparkling, still or flavored water can be handed out as a default and advertised on the menu.
Democratic Sen. Bill Monning says his measure aims to combat diabetes, obesity and other health problems in California.
Both laws take effect Jan. 1, 2019.
The Business Journal contributed to this report.